Skip to content
HaulMate
  • Moving
  • Comparison
  • Tips

Rent a Truck or Hire a Local Driver? How to Choose for a Small Haul

Renting a truck gives you control, hiring a local driver gives you convenience. Here is how the two compare on cost, effort, risk and time, so you can pick the right one for your load.

By HaulMate Team3 min read

Rental box truck parked beside a building, ready to be loaded

When you have something big to move, there are two common routes: rent a truck and do it yourself, or hire a local driver to do the hauling. Both work. Which one is better depends on the size of the job and how much of it you want to do yourself.

What renting a truck really involves

Renting is simple in theory. You pick up a van or truck, load it, drive it, unload it and bring it back. In practice, the total includes more than the headline rate:

  • The rental fee, often charged by the day or by the hour.
  • Mileage charges, and the fuel you have to put back in.
  • Insurance or damage cover, which you may need to buy separately.
  • Moving blankets, straps or a dolly, if they are not included.
  • Your own time, including the trip to collect the truck and the trip to return it.

It also needs a second person for anything heavy, and you need to be comfortable driving a larger vehicle, especially in tight streets and car parks.

What hiring a local driver involves

With a local driver, you describe the job and the driver brings a vehicle that fits it. You pay for the trip, not for a whole vehicle on a day-long clock. A good driver will have straps, blankets and a plan for loading.

The things to check are what the driver will carry versus what you need to carry, how the price is set, and how the driver is vetted. We cover the last point in our checklist for choosing a hauling driver.

Side-by-side

Rent a truckHire a local driver
Who drivesYouThe driver
Who loadsYou and your helperDepends on the job; agree it up front
Cost shapeDay or hour rate, plus mileage, fuel and coverPrice for the trip
Best forMany items, a full move, long loading timeOne or a few items, short distances
EffortHighLow
RiskYou are responsible for the vehicleThe driver is responsible for the vehicle

When renting makes sense

  • You are moving a whole home or most of a room.
  • You want to take your time loading and unloading.
  • You already have helpers and are comfortable driving a large vehicle.

When hiring a driver makes sense

  • You are moving one big item or a small number of things.
  • The distance is short and the trip is a one-off.
  • You do not have a vehicle that fits, or anyone to help lift.
  • You want it done today without spending the afternoon returning a truck.

A rough way to decide

Ask yourself three questions:

  1. Can I do the lifting and driving myself? If not, hire a driver.
  2. Is it one trip or many? One or two short trips usually favours a driver. A full day of loading and shuttling favours a rental.
  3. What is my time worth? If collecting, filling and returning a truck eats half a day, the cheaper rate may not be cheaper.

For price factors on a driver quote, see how much local furniture delivery costs.

Where HaulMate fits

HaulMate is for the second case. You add a pickup and drop-off and a photo of what you are moving, and a nearby driver with a small or big truck can accept the job. You see the suggested price before you send the request, and you follow the delivery step by step, with a photo at pickup and another at drop-off.

Neither route is right for every job. Match the choice to the size of what you are moving, and you will save both money and effort.

Get your stuff home.

Download HaulMate free on iPhone and Android. Your first delivery is a few taps away.